What’s better for excess stock: reselling or recycling? It depends on the condition of your inventory and your goals. Reselling works best for functional, in-demand items, helping you recover costs and reduce waste. Recycling is ideal for damaged, expired, or hazardous goods, ensuring proper disposal while reclaiming raw materials.
Key Takeaways:
- Reselling recovers 60–80% of a product's value, extends its lifecycle, and is suitable for items like electronics, clothing, and non-perishables.
- Recycling handles damaged or obsolete goods, recovering materials like metals and plastics but often incurs processing costs.
- Reselling is more profitable and resource-efficient, while recycling is a fallback for items unfit for resale.
Quick Tip: Start with reselling whenever possible, as it retains more value and reduces waste. Only recycle when resale isn’t viable.
Resell and Recycle Excess Inventory Profitably: Business losses are recouped & capital is preserved
What Is Reselling for Excess Stock?
Reselling, often referred to as recommerce, involves selling previously owned, used, refurbished, or excess inventory through secondary channels. Instead of discarding surplus items, businesses can sell them to bulk buyers, jobbers, or through B2B platforms. This approach not only extends the life of products but also keeps usable items out of landfills. In fact, the recommerce market is expected to hit $84 billion by 2030, growing 11 times faster than the overall retail industry. Plus, purchasing just one used item can slash its carbon, waste, and water footprints by 82%.
Reselling is particularly effective for items that are new, like-new, refurbished, or have minor cosmetic imperfections. Popular categories include electronics like smartphones and laptops, clothing, home goods, and specialized equipment. The secondhand apparel market alone is projected to grow to $350 billion by 2028. Below, we’ll explore how reselling works, its benefits and challenges, and when it’s the best option.
How Reselling Works
There are several ways businesses can channel their excess stock into secondary markets. One option is selling in bulk to jobbers - large-scale liquidators who purchase inventory at reduced prices and resell it through their own networks. Alternatively, companies can use B2B auction platforms and surplus marketplaces like ForthClear, which directly connects sellers with verified bulk buyers. Some businesses even establish internal buyback or trade-in programs, offering customers immediate incentives while efficiently managing refurbished goods.
ForthClear, for example, streamlines the process by automatically identifying unsold stock (sitting for over 60 days) and enabling quick listings. Its integration with Stripe escrow payments ensures secure transactions, holding funds until delivery is confirmed. This reduces fraud risk and fosters trust in B2B exchanges.
The condition of inventory plays a key role in resale success. Items with high residual value and adequate shelf life - such as non-perishable goods, electronics, apparel, and durable items - are ideal candidates for reselling. For technology assets, certified data sanitization is critical to protect intellectual property and ensure consumer privacy.
Pros and Cons of Reselling
Understanding how reselling operates also means weighing its financial and environmental benefits against potential challenges.
"Direct-to-consumer marketplaces provide great engagement with the end buyers. And the closer we can get to the end buyers, the higher the revenue recovery."
- Mary Cho, Director of Client Solutions, Liquidity Services
Reselling offers businesses a chance to recover a significant portion of their investment. Companies can often reclaim 60% to 80% of MSRP on inventory that might otherwise yield minimal returns through traditional liquidation methods. This process boosts ROI, frees up capital, and reduces warehouse costs, all while making room for new stock. Beyond the financial upside, reselling also has environmental benefits, as it avoids the need for new manufacturing. Producing new goods often consumes significant resources; for instance, creating one garment typically requires 77 gallons of water and emits 17 pounds of CO₂ equivalent.
However, reselling isn’t without its challenges. Liquidation pricing means businesses usually don’t recover the full original cost, and there’s always the risk of products entering unauthorized channels (gray markets), which can harm a brand’s reputation or violate distribution agreements. Additionally, companies must ensure items haven’t been officially recalled, as selling such products is illegal. For electronics and IT assets, secure data destruction is a must to prevent privacy breaches. Fees on resale platforms can also vary widely; for instance, eBay charges around 3% or more, while Poshmark takes a 20% cut on sales over $15.
When to Choose Reselling
Reselling works best for functional, low-risk items with remaining shelf life, especially new or like-new products, refurbished electronics, or off-season inventory that can’t return to primary sales channels. It’s particularly useful when storage costs are becoming a burden. Businesses with efficient reverse logistics systems can recover up to 65% of the original value of returned or surplus goods.
Tools like ForthClear’s dead-stock detection make this process even easier by flagging unsold items after 60 days. Automated systems and trade-in programs not only speed up reselling but also encourage eco-conscious practices by extending product lifespans and minimizing storage fees.
Reselling is also a smart choice when there’s strong demand in secondary markets. For example, high-demand items like lawnmowers or power tools are often liquidated at 10-15% of their original retail price. Interestingly, about 50% of resale buyers are entirely new to the brand, making reselling a potential customer acquisition strategy as well.
Whenever possible, prioritize reselling over recycling. Recycling requires additional energy to break items down into raw materials, while reselling preserves the product as-is, maximizing the value of the labor and resources already invested in its production.
What Is Recycling for Excess Stock?
Recycling involves taking materials that would otherwise be discarded and transforming them into raw materials for new products. Unlike reselling, which keeps the product intact, recycling breaks items down to recover materials like metals, plastics, glass, or fibers . This makes recycling the go-to choice for items that are damaged beyond repair, expired, recalled, or unsuitable for resale. When a product can no longer serve its intended purpose, recycling helps businesses reclaim value while reducing landfill waste. For example, in 2018, recycling and composting municipal solid waste in the U.S. prevented over 193 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions. Recycling is especially critical for regulated or hazardous materials. In 2017, over 1.5 million tons of hazardous waste were processed using methods like metals recovery and solvent regeneration.
How Recycling Works
Recycling follows a three-step process: collection, processing, and remanufacturing. First, materials are gathered and sorted by type. Then, they are cleaned, decontaminated, and broken down. For simpler materials like aluminum or cardboard, this might involve shredding and compacting. More complex items, such as electronics, require manual disassembly to remove reusable parts and hazardous components like batteries or mercury switches before undergoing industrial shredding .
"Physical destruction breaks [an asset] down into high-quality resources for reuse as raw materials... the device cannot be reused as originally intended." - Robert Reed, Director of Marketing and PR, Sunnking Sustainable Solutions
After shredding, valuable materials are separated mechanically. Strong magnets extract ferrous metals like iron and steel, while eddy currents separate non-ferrous metals such as aluminum and copper. Plastics are sorted using density separation. These recovered materials are then refined. Metals are purified through high-heat processes, plastics are cleaned and turned into pellets, and chemicals like spent solvents are regenerated for reuse . Electronics recycling often involves recovering precious metals like gold, silver, and platinum, with physical destruction ensuring complete data security.
Pros and Cons of Recycling
Recycling helps reduce landfill waste, limits the need for extracting new raw materials, and conserves energy. For instance, recycling just 10 plastic bottles saves enough energy to power a laptop for over 25 hours. The recycling and reuse industry in the U.S. supports around 681,000 jobs, generates $37.8 billion in wages, and contributes $5.5 billion in tax revenues annually. It also ensures compliant disposal for regulated inventory, helping businesses meet environmental goals and avoid regulatory risks. Proper recycling prevents substandard or unsafe items from entering secondary markets, protecting both public safety and brand reputation.
However, recycling has its downsides. The process typically recovers only the scrap value of materials rather than the full product value. Processing costs can be high, especially for items that require specialized handling. Businesses must work with trustworthy recyclers to avoid "sham recycling", where hazardous waste isn’t properly managed . Additionally, current recycling infrastructure struggles to keep up with the complexity of modern products, creating logistical challenges . For electronics, physical destruction guarantees data security but only recovers material value, while methods like data wiping allow for refurbishment and resale .
When to Choose Recycling
Recycling is the best option for items that are damaged, non-functional, expired, or pose safety risks. Salvage inventory - like broken electronics, damaged parts, expired chemicals, or structurally defective products - should be recycled. Recalled items must also be recycled instead of resold. Hazardous materials, such as batteries, pesticides, mercury-containing equipment, and aerosol cans classified as universal waste, require specialized recycling to ensure safe handling. For regulated materials, recycling is not just a practical choice - it’s often a legal requirement that helps businesses avoid liability and environmental violations.
Recycling also protects brand integrity. For instance, when excess stock doesn’t meet quality standards, recycling prevents substandard items from tarnishing a brand’s reputation. A good example is For Days’ "Take Back Bag" program, introduced in October 2024, which lets customers return old garments to be recycled into new textiles. Similarly, Levi Strauss & Co. uses its "Levi's SecondHand" platform to assess whether returned denim can be resold. Items that don’t meet resale standards are recycled into new fibers, as seen with their circular 501® jeans made from Renewcell's Circulose® fiber.
When recycling electronics or IT assets, it’s crucial to work with certified recyclers, such as those with R2v3 certification, to ensure proper data handling and a secure chain of custody. Verify that recyclers comply with environmental regulations and carry pollution liability insurance. For sensitive data, physical destruction methods like shredding or melting are more secure than software-based data clearing.
Recycling should always be considered a last resort, after reselling options are exhausted. The waste management hierarchy prioritizes reuse over recycling because reuse preserves the product as a whole, while recycling consumes additional energy to break it down into raw materials.
This approach highlights when recycling is most effective, a topic explored further in the comparison with reselling.
sbb-itb-bc600a0
Recycling vs. Reselling: Direct Comparison
Recycling vs Reselling Excess Stock: Complete Comparison Guide
Comparison Table: Recycling vs. Reselling
When dealing with excess stock, the choice between recycling and reselling depends on several key factors. According to the EPA, source reduction and reuse (reselling) are the most environmentally preferred strategies, with recycling coming next in line.
| Criterion | Reselling (Reuse) | Recycling |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Recover revenue and maximize profit | Divert waste and recover materials |
| Financial Outcome | Recovers part of the original product's value | Generates returns based on commodity prices or involves processing fees |
| Environmental Impact | Saves resources by extending product lifecycles and reducing the need for new manufacturing | Offers moderate savings but requires energy for processing and collection |
| Inventory Condition | Suitable for functional, gently used, or retail-ready items | Best for damaged, obsolete, or hazardous goods |
| Operational Complexity | Requires market research, listings, and shipping logistics | Involves sorting, hauling, and certified processing |
| Data Security | Higher risk; demands thorough data wiping for electronics | Lower risk; physical destruction ensures data erasure |
| Brand Protection | Risk of market dilution if not carefully managed | Prevents substandard items from affecting brand reputation |
| Regulatory Compliance | Must meet refurbishing standards and resale laws | Must comply with environmental and hazardous waste regulations |
A great example of balancing these approaches comes from IBM. In 2022, the company resold 35.6% of its end-of-life products and recycled 58.6%, sending just 0.4% to landfills. This table highlights the trade-offs, helping guide strategic decisions.
The financial aspect is a big consideration. Reselling lets you recover part of a product's original value, whereas recycling often yields returns tied to commodity prices. For instance, aluminum cans fetch around $0.50 per pound, and baled cardboard is valued between $20–$26 per ton. Additionally, recycling can cut waste disposal and hauling costs by as much as 50%.
How to Decide Between Recycling and Reselling
Using the criteria above, start by assessing your inventory based on condition and demand. Reselling is ideal for functional, in-demand items, while recycling is better for goods that can’t be restored to a sellable state.
Regulations are another critical factor. Hazardous materials - like batteries, pesticides, and certain electronics - must follow strict recycling protocols instead of being resold. For IT assets, certified data destruction is essential to avoid data breaches that could erase any financial gains.
Next, factor in total costs. Consider shipping, transaction fees (such as a 5% fee), and storage costs for reselling. Compare these with recycling's processing and transportation expenses. If warehouse costs outweigh resale margins, quick liquidation may be the better option.
Finally, think about your sustainability goals and brand reputation. Reselling extends product lifecycles and supports the circular economy. However, controlling where your surplus inventory ends up is crucial to protect your brand. Recycling, on the other hand, signals corporate responsibility by ensuring substandard items don’t harm your reputation. Still, it should be a last resort after resale options are explored. Align your decision with both financial and environmental priorities to maintain a sustainable supply chain.
"Products should only be recycled if they cannot be reduced or reused." - U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
For electronics, platforms like ForthClear (https://forthclear.io) simplify reselling by connecting you with verified bulk buyers. Their secure Stripe escrow payments and automated dead stock detection for items unsold for over 60 days make the process efficient and fraud-resistant.
Using Both Methods Together
When it comes to maximizing value, the real win lies in combining recycling and reselling strategically. A great example of this is a Fortune-500 utility company that managed to save big by adopting this dual approach. They internally redeployed two GE Frame 5 turbines, saving $14 million in capital expenses. At the same time, they auctioned off remaining parts for a net gain of $2.6 million and sent scrap materials to an R2-certified recycler. This strategy not only met audit requirements but also kept 870 tons of material out of landfills.
To successfully integrate both methods, a structured six-phase framework is key: Identification, Evaluation, Segregation, Valuation, Disposition, and Reporting. Start by conducting a thorough inventory audit to categorize your stock. For example, you might classify items into new or unused goods for full-price resale, refurbished items for repair and resale, and outdated materials for recycling. Each item should be assessed for its functional condition, market demand, data security risks, and environmental impact. This structured process lays the groundwork for leveraging automation to make smarter, faster decisions.
Automation is a game changer. Tools powered by AI, such as market scans and predictive analytics, can determine whether an item should be resold or scrapped for its raw materials. For instance, ForthClear (https://forthclear.io) identifies unsold stock (sitting for over 60 days) and connects sellers with verified bulk buyers, all while using secure Stripe escrow payments to ensure smooth transactions.
The financial and environmental benefits of this approach are hard to ignore. High-quality reselling can recover 10–30 cents for every dollar invested, while redeploying assets internally can yield a full 100% return by avoiding new purchases. On the sustainability side, recycling or reusing just one ton of waste can prevent up to 3 tons of CO2 emissions. Even extending the lifespan of electronic devices by a single year could reduce global e-waste by 16%.
"You can't manage what you don't measure." - INV Recovery
To maximize results, track key performance indicators like inventory turnover, recovery costs, and landfill diversion rates. Building relationships with liquidators and certified recyclers ensures you have multiple options for surplus stock. This dual strategy not only boosts financial recovery but also enhances sustainability, proving you don’t have to choose one over the other.
Conclusion
Choosing between reselling and recycling excess inventory comes down to the condition of your stock. Reselling ranks higher on the EPA's waste management hierarchy because it keeps products in use longer and recovers more value. On the other hand, recycling is a backup option for items that can't be reused or resold. For functional, in-demand items like overstock, seasonal goods, or customer returns in good shape, reselling is the way to go. Recycling, however, works best for damaged goods, outdated materials, or items with no resale market.
The financial aspect also plays a big role. Reselling helps you recover part of your initial investment and retain some profit, whereas recycling typically only covers processing costs.
Act quickly to evaluate your inventory. High-demand brands with active secondary markets are ideal for reselling. Meanwhile, items like end-of-life electronics are better suited for recycling. Don’t forget practical concerns like data security when dealing with electronics.
"Reduction and reuse are the most effective ways you can save natural resources, protect the environment and save money." - U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Aligning your inventory decisions with sustainability goals is a win-win. By combining efficient stock assessment with eco-conscious practices, you can boost both profits and sustainability. Tools like ForthClear’s automated stock detection and secure connections to bulk buyers can help you recover more financial value while supporting environmentally friendly practices.
FAQs
What’s the best way for businesses to handle excess stock: reselling or recycling?
Deciding between reselling and recycling comes down to factors like the condition of your items, market demand, and your business objectives. If your products are still functional and sought-after, reselling can be a smart move. It not only brings in revenue but also helps cut down on storage costs. Platforms like ForthClear simplify this process by letting you list surplus inventory, connect with verified buyers, and handle secure transactions. This is particularly useful for items that are seasonal, trendy, or still hold market value.
On the flip side, recycling is the go-to option for items that are damaged, outdated, or simply unsellable. Recycling contributes to sustainability efforts by minimizing landfill waste and advancing eco-friendly practices. It also supports corporate ESG goals and might even save money through tax incentives or lower disposal fees.
When deciding, weigh the product’s condition, its resale potential, and the costs tied to recycling or disposal. Striking the right balance ensures you make a choice that’s both financially sound and environmentally conscious.
What makes reselling more environmentally friendly than recycling?
Reselling, a practice that focuses on giving products a second life, often has a smaller environmental footprint compared to recycling. Why? Because it keeps the original manufacturing effort intact. Instead of breaking down materials through energy-heavy recycling processes like collection, shredding, and reprocessing, reselling allows businesses to pass surplus items directly to new owners. This approach cuts down on greenhouse gas emissions, saves raw materials, and reduces waste.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) places reuse above recycling in its waste management hierarchy for this very reason - it has a lower environmental toll. By reselling, businesses not only keep items out of landfills but also curb the demand for new production, preserving the energy and resources already invested in the original product. It’s a practical, planet-friendly way for companies to handle excess inventory while making a positive impact.
What impacts the profitability of reselling surplus inventory?
The profitability of reselling surplus inventory hinges on a few critical factors.
First, carrying costs can significantly impact your bottom line. Unsold stock doesn't just take up space - it drains resources. In the U.S., businesses often spend 20-30% of their inventory's value on storage and related expenses. Spotting slow-moving items early can help minimize these costs. Strategies like competitive pricing or bundling can also speed up sales, reducing the financial drag of unused inventory.
Second, demand forecasting and data-driven pricing are game-changers. Leveraging tools to predict demand and set smart prices helps keep overstock in check while maximizing resale value. The condition and relevance of your products are equally important. Items in good shape that align with seasonal or market trends are more likely to sell at higher prices. On the flip side, outdated or damaged goods might need repairs or alternative disposal options to recover value.
Finally, the efficiency of the resale process plays a big role in profitability. Features like secure payment systems, verified buyers, and bulk pricing can simplify transactions and protect your margins. By streamlining the process, businesses can turn surplus inventory into a profitable opportunity rather than a costly burden.
